Book Contends Diversity of Thought Overlooked at Politically Correct Universities

February, 2010

FAYETTEVILLE, Ark. – Political correctness in higher education puts a damper on critical thought and research that could be considered too controversial, according to a University of Arkansas professor who co-edited a new book on the subject.

Robert Maranto

Robert Maranto

"Important research questions are not being asked or are being asked in the wrong way because we don't have enough diversity of thought," said Robert Maranto. "Conservative perspectives are underrepresented in higher education, which makes universities dull places."

Maranto, University of Arkansas professor of education reform, was lead editor of the volume titled The Politically Correct University: Problems, Scope, and Reforms published by American Enterprise Institute Press. Maranto gave a talk on the book Feb. 23 at the Clinton School of Public Service in Little Rock followed by a book signing.

The book's other editors are Richard E. Redding of Chapman University School of Law and Frederick M. Hess, director of education policy studies for the American Enterprise Institute.

Higher education institutions put great emphasis on promoting diversity, according to the editors, but these initiatives usually focus on race, ethnicity, gender and sexual orientation, not necessarily on ideas. Some researchers with conservative views on important social and policy issues such as crime, education, foreign policy, and welfare programs have had difficulty finding academic posts over the years, Maranto said.

Images of academia as a stronghold of liberal thinking are not new, but this new book offers a unique perspective, he said.

"The authors of these chapters present information that uses social science methods and data, rather than anecdotes, to describe what's going on," Maranto explained. "In the book, we make the case that reform of universities needs to come from inside. The editors like universities. We want to build them up, not tear them down."

Maranto book

The Politically Correct University

Some findings noted in the book:

  • Conservatives and libertarians among college and university faculty are outnumbered by liberals and radicals by 3-to-1 in economics, more than 5-to-1 in political science and 20-to-1 or more in anthropology and sociology.
  • Conservative undergraduates lack role models who share their political views, have more distant relationships to faculty and may have fewer opportunities to do research with their professors, all of which may affect whether they pursue doctoral degrees.
  • While the most important factor in career success for faculty is a publication track record, holding socially conservative views has a statistically significant negative impact on career success – equal to about one-third the impact of publications.

"I worked in government during the Clinton years and felt in sync with most of what the Clinton administration wanted to do," Maranto said, "but in academia I'm often considered a raging right-winger. In some ways, that was the genesis of this book."

A dearth of conservative, libertarian and neoliberal thinkers at universities hinders these institutions in one of their most important purposes, that of producing thoughtful citizens, the chapter authors write. They offer a range of solutions such as establishing programs or centers within universities that operate outside official departments and allow conservative faculty members to freely explore particular topics with sympathetic students. They also advocate a larger role for alumni and trustees in overseeing institutions and a change in how liberal arts scholars understand themselves, not as provocative debunkers of accepted ideas, but as discoverers of truth.

Maranto attributes the tendency of professors to hold similar views to simple human nature: "We professors are just like anyone else. We tend to want to hire and promote people like themselves. That's natural, but it's not always best for the organization."

###

Do you have a story idea, a question or comments you would like to share? Contact us

Submit information about College of Education and Health Professions alumni to Heidi Stambuck at stambuck@uark.edu or 479-575-3138
or to the Arkansas Alumni Association at records@razorbackroad.com or P.O. Box 1070, Fayetteville, AR 72702.